Skip to content
Book a free discovery call

Articles

Why Small Email Lists Outperform Big Ones

Why Small Email Lists Outperform Big Ones

Higher Logic data shows small association email sends open at 48%. Here's why broad newsletters are quietly killing engagement — and what to do instead.

Your members aren’t ignoring you. You’re just talking to too many of them at once. 
Most associations respond to weak email numbers the same way. They send more. More newsletters, more reminders, more “one last chance” nudges. The logic feels sound. If people are not engaging, put more in front of them. Widen the net. The data says the net is the problem.
Higher Logic runs the largest email benchmark study in the association world. Their 2024 report looked at more than two billion emails from over 1,500 associations. The headline most people quoted was the drop in open rates, from around 38% to around 36% in a year.
That is real, and I will come back to it, because part of that fall is a measurement trick rather than a real decline, and you deserve to know which.
But the number that actually matters got almost no attention.
Emails sent to small lists, under 500 people, opened at close to 48% and clicked at over 8%. As the lists got bigger, both numbers fell. Not held steady. Fell. The broader the send, the worse it performed, all the way down the scale.
Read that again with your own sends in mind. Your smallest, most specific email to a narrow slice of members almost certainly outperforms your big all-member newsletter by a wide margin. You have probably seen this in your own reports and filed it as a fluke. It is not a fluke. It is the pattern.

Here is why it happens, and it is not complicated.

When you send the same thing to everyone, most of it is irrelevant to most of them. A newmember welcome series, an event three cities away, a policy update for one committee, a discount on a product half your members will never buy. Each person gets a stream where a little is for them, and most is not. The brain learns fast. After a few of these, your name in the inbox becomes a low-value signal, and it gets skimmed past without a thought. You trained them to ignore you, one irrelevant send at a time.
Your members are already telling you this. In the same body of research, half of members say they get too many emails. Not too few. Too many. So the instinct to fix weak engagement by sending more is not just ineffective. It actively speeds up the decline.
You are pouring water into a bucket with a hole and wondering why the level keeps dropping.
Now, the caveat I promised, because it matters and because you will hear it from someone eventually. The fall in open rates over the last couple of years is partly artificial.
Apple Mail Privacy Protection loads email images in the background, which registers as an “open” whether or not a human ever looked. On top of that, changes from Gmail and Yahoo shifted how bulk mail is handled. So opens have become a noisy, unreliable number, and anyone who leans their whole argument on the open-rate drop is standing on soft ground.
But notice this. The Apple problem inflates opens. It makes the numbers look better than reality, not worse. And even with that thumb on the scale, the small-list advantage still shows up clearly. The pattern is not a measurement artefact. If anything, the false opens are
hiding just how strong the small-list effect really is. That is why I trust the segmentation finding far more than the raw open-rate trend, and why you should too.
So the honest scoreboard is this. Opens are a weak signal now. Clicks are a better one, because a click is a real human choosing to act, and Apple cannot fake that. And on clicks, the small, relevant send wins comfortably.
None of this is really about email. Email is just the place where the data happens to be clean enough to prove the point. The same principle runs through everything you publish. The broad, safe, for-everyone message is the one nobody feels was written for them, so nobody
acts on it. Relevance is not a nice-to-have that sits on top of reach. Relevance is what produces reach in the first place.
Which leaves most associations with an uncomfortable choice, because the usual instinct points the wrong way.
The instinct is to grow the list and send to all of it, because a big number feels like progress.
The evidence says do the opposite. Send less to any one person. Send more of what is actually for them. Split your members by what they care about, by their stage, by their committee, by their region, and let each group get a stream that feels like it was built for them. Your total sends might go up. Your sends to any single member should go down. And
the share of people who open, read, and act should climb.
This is harder than sending one newsletter to everyone. It asks you to know your members well enough to divide them sensibly, and to have the tools that make that division easy rather than a monthly chore. That is a real cost, and I am not going to pretend it is free.
But the alternative is the slow death you are already watching in your reports. A list that grows on paper while fewer and fewer of the people on it can be bothered to open anything
you send. A big number that means less every quarter.
The associations that will still have your members’ attention in five years are not the ones sending the most. They are the ones sending the least that is irrelevant.
Start there. Look at your last all-member send, and ask honestly what share of it was truly for each person who received it. That number is your real open rate waiting to happen.