Nobody Complains. They Just Don’t Renew.
Open last year’s renewals report. Find the members who lapsed with no reason code recorded.
That’s most of them, isn’t it?
Somewhere in that list are people who tried to renew and couldn’t. Couldn’t afford it. Couldn’t use it. The session timed out halfway through a fourteen-field form. The card field had no label, so their screen reader announced it as “edit text, blank.”
The CAPTCHA had no audio option. The renewal notice was a PDF that turned out to be a scan of a printed letter. None of them told you.
The Click-Away Pound research found that only 8% of disabled users who hit a barrier on a website will contact the organisation about it. The other 92% go elsewhere.
In retail, that’s an abandoned basket. In an association it’s a fellow of eighteen years, and it arrives in your board pack labelled “attrition.”
Associations get hit harder than shops do
A retailer loses a stranger who probably wasn’t coming back anyway. You lose someone whose lifetime value is enormous and whose loyalty was, until that Tuesday afternoon, unshakeable.
It comes down to who your members are and how they age.
A quarter of the UK population is disabled, according to the DWP’s Family Resources Survey. Among working-age adults it has climbed from 17% to 23% in ten years. But population prevalence isn’t the number that matters here. What matters is prevalence across your membership, and your membership skews older than the working population as a whole, because that’s what professional bodies do. People join at 25 and stay for forty years.
So the member most likely to hit a barrier on your website is also your longest-serving, highest-value, most loyal one. The person who acquired sight loss at 62. The member managing arthritis who can’t use a mouse precisely any more. The one whose chronic fatigue turns an eleven minute form into a form they abandon.
Accessibility failure doesn’t cost you the members you never had. It costs you the ones you already earned.
It probably isn’t who you think it is, Ask most association teams what accessibility means and you’ll hear “screen readers” and “blind members.”
That’s a small slice of it.
The Family Resources Survey found the two most common impairment types among working-age adults are mental health conditions, reported by 48% of disabled people in that group, and mobility impairments at 42%.
That changes what you’re actually fixing. The majority case isn’t specialist assistive technology at all. It’s cognitive load, fatigue, anxiety and motor control. Which means the things quietly costing you renewals look like this:
- A renewal form with fourteen fields and no way to save and come back
- A session that times out with no warning
- Error messages that appear at the top of the page and don’t say what went wrong
- A membership category structure so tangled the applicant genuinely can’t work out which one they are
- Small tap targets on the payment screen
- Pale grey text on white, still the most common failure on the web.
None of that needs a specialist. Most of it is design debt you’ve been carrying since the last rebuild.
The widget didn’t fix it.
Plenty of associations have already “handled” this by pasting in an accessibility overlay. The little icon in the corner that pops out a panel offering bigger fonts and a dyslexia friendly mode.
It’s worth knowing what happened to that industry.
In January 2025, the US Federal Trade Commission fined accessiBe, one of the largest overlay vendors, a million dollars over marketing claims that its AI widget would automatically bring websites into line with WCAG 2.1 AA.
UsableNet’s analysis found that a quarter of digital accessibility lawsuits targeted sites that were using overlays. Not
protected by them. Targeted because of them, with the overlay itself named as a barrier.
If you bought one, you didn’t buy compliance. You bought a badge. And more expensively, you bought the belief that the job was done, which is why nobody has looked at your join form in four years.
The debt is getting bigger, not smaller.
WebAIM scans the top million home pages every year. Their 2026 report found 95.9% had detectable WCAG failures, up from 94.8%, which reverses six years of slow improvement. Average errors per page went up 10% to 56.1.
The reason is worth sitting with. Average page complexity jumped 22.5% in a single year.
Sites are being built faster and heavier than anyone is fixing them. And 96% of all detected errors still fall into the same six basic categories they’ve fallen into for seven years running.
That’s what makes this a trap rather than a task. Every year you defer, there’s more of it.
Fixing your website in 2029 will cost noticeably more than fixing the same website in 2026, because by then there’ll be more website to fix.
The awkward governance question
Here’s the version of this I’d put to a board rather than a marketing team.
Your association’s authority rests on one claim. That you represent the profession.
Not part of it. It. That claim is what gets you into the consultation, the negotiation, the standards committee, the room. If a meaningful chunk of that profession can’t complete your application form, the claim is quietly untrue. And nobody in your building knows by how much, because the people it excludes never filed a complaint.
That isn’t a moral point. It’s a mandate point.
Yes, there’s a legal angle. It’s smaller than you’ve been told.
I’ll be straight about this, because most accessibility content isn’t.
In the UK, the Equality Act 2010 has required service providers to make anticipatory reasonable adjustments, websites included, since it came into force. That’s real, and it applies to you. But it has been in force for fifteen years and has produced no UK web accessibility court case. A handful of matters settled quietly. The best known is RNIB’s action against BMIbaby.
The European Accessibility Act, which became applicable in June 2025, is being enforced.
French authorities issued notices to four major retailers in November 2025 with emergency injunctions following, aimed at checkout flows and missing accessibility statements.
Sweden’s regulator opened e-commerce cases and has taken well over a hundred public complaints. But the EAA is not UK law. It never became retained EU law and no UK equivalent is proposed. It only bites on you if you sell to consumers in the EU, which, if you run events or e-commerce for EU based members, you might.
Two exceptions worth checking properly. If your body confers a professional qualification, Section 53 of the Equality Act puts a specific duty on you to make reasonable adjustments in assessment, and you can’t charge the candidate for them. And if you’re mostly publicly funded, or you deliver services essential to the public, you may sit inside the Public Sector Bodies Accessibility Regulations despite being a charity.
But if fear of enforcement is what finally moves your organisation, you’ve picked the weakest reason available. The strong reason is sitting in your renewals report.
What I’d actually do, in order
1. Instrument the exit. Add a reason code to lapse. Ask leavers one question. You can’t fix what you refuse to measure.
2. Test the three flows that carry money and mandate. Join, renew, book an event. Not the homepage. Nobody lapses because of your homepage.
3. Run those flows keyboard only. No mouse. If you can’t renew using the Tab key, neither can some of your members. Fifteen minutes, no budget.
4. Fix the six. Contrast, alt text, form labels, link text, headings, page language. They account for the overwhelming majority of detectable failures, and they’re cheap.
5. Cut fields. Every field you take off the join form is an accessibility win, a conversion win and a data quality win at the same time. There’s no trade-off to argue about.
6. Take the overlay off. Then audit properly.
7. Publish an accessibility statement that says what’s still broken and when you’ll fix it. Being honest about the gaps is a feature, not a risk.
None of that is a project. It’s about a fortnight.
Send me the URL of your join form, and I’ll tell you what breaks on it. No pitch, no templated report, just what I find.
Send me an email: @am@senior.co.uk