Skip to content
Book a free discovery call

Articles

Why Member Engagement Drops After Year One

Why Member Engagement Drops After Year One

Choosing the right content management system (CMS) is a pivotal decision for any membership organisation or association. Drupal is a popular open-source platform with a track record of powering complex, content-rich websites. But is it the best fit for your membership organisation? Here’s what you need to know about Drupal’s strengths, weaknesses, and alternatives—plus best practices for getting the most out of your CMS.


The Benefits of Drupal for Membership Organisations

Drupal has been a trusted CMS for many membership bodies, charities, and professional associations—especially those with complex digital needs. Key benefits include:

  • Highly Flexible and Customisable: Drupal can support a wide range of features: member directories, event management, CPD tracking, forums, and more. Its modular architecture allows you to build bespoke workflows and content types.

  • Open Source: No licensing fees and a large, active global community continually developing new modules and features.

  • Integration-Friendly: Drupal’s robust API and integration capabilities make it possible to connect with CRMs, event platforms, payment gateways, and other essential systems.

  • Strong Security: Regular security updates and a dedicated security team make Drupal a dependable platform for organisations handling sensitive member data.

  • Scalable: Drupal is designed to handle large volumes of users, content, and traffic, making it suitable for growing organisations.

Drawbacks and Challenges of Drupal

Despite its strengths, Drupal isn’t always the best fit for every membership organisation—especially smaller teams or those with limited technical resources. Consider these potential drawbacks:

  • Steep Learning Curve: Drupal is developer-centric. Even day-to-day content management can feel daunting for non-technical staff.

  • Scarcity of Skilled Developers: Experienced Drupal developers are in high demand and can be hard to find, which pushes up the cost of development and support.

  • Higher Ongoing Costs: Maintenance, upgrades, and security patches often require specialist input, adding to long-term costs.

  • Complex Upgrades: Major version upgrades (e.g., from Drupal 8 to 9) can require significant redevelopment and planning.

  • Potential Overkill: For organisations with simple requirements, Drupal’s complexity may be unnecessary and could lead to higher costs and longer timelines.

Best Practices for Using Drupal in Membership Organisations

If you’re already using Drupal or planning a Drupal project, here are some tips to maximise its value:

1.   Work with Sector Specialists: Choose an agency or partner with proven Drupal and membership sector experience.

2.   Prioritise Security and Updates: Stay current with core and module updates to protect your site and comply with data protection regulations.

3.   Invest in Training: Ensure your team receives proper training in content management, workflows, and basic troubleshooting.

4.   Plan for Upgrades: Budget for periodic upgrades and major version migrations.

5.   Document Customisations: Keep clear records of bespoke development and integrations to simplify future upgrades or transitions.


Alternatives to Drupal: Why Consider Umbraco?

While Drupal is powerful, it’s not the only CMS option—especially for small and medium-sized membership organisations seeking a balance of flexibility, security, and ease of use.

Why Umbraco?

  • Built on .NET for Enhanced Security:The .NET framework is trusted by major enterprises for its safety, reliability, and long-term support.

  • User-Friendly:Umbraco’s intuitive interface makes content management straightforward for non-technical teams.

  • Easier to Find Developers:.NET developers are more widely available, making support and future development more cost-effective than Drupal.

  • Flexible and Customisable:Like Drupal, Umbraco can be tailored to your organisation’s needs—but often with less technical overhead.

  • Smooth Upgrades and Maintenance:Upgrades are typically less disruptive, lowering the risk of costly rebuilds.

  • Strong Integration Capabilities:Seamlessly connects with CRMs, event platforms, payment gateways, and more.

  • No Licensing Fees:Like Drupal, Umbraco is open source and cost-effective.

Our Perspective

We support both Drupal and Umbraco, and can help you succeed on either platform. But for most small and medium membership organisations, Umbraco offers the best balance of flexibility, security, and ease of use—without the high costs and resource headaches.


Conclusion & Next Steps

Drupal remains a strong choice for large, complex organisations with in-house technical expertise and demanding digital requirements. But for many membership organisations, the drawbacks—especially developer scarcity and ongoing costs—can outweigh the benefits.

If you’re seeking a future-proof, cost-effective, and user-friendly CMS, Umbraco is a compelling alternative. It empowers your team, streamlines admin, and keeps your organisation secure and agile.

Thinking about your next CMS move or considering a migration?
We’re happy to help you compare options, plan a seamless transition, and choose the best platform for your organisation’s future.

senior.co.uk/contact/ or get in touch for a chat about your digital roadmap.